Quote: LOVE v. HATE

T WOULD SEEM that we ought no longer to hide behind the

I even the

theory of punishment, nor even the term itself, that we should give up this effort to bend others to our will by making them suffer if they do not obey. We have long since abandoned such methods in our educational system, as applied to children particularly, and have come to believe that character can unfold at its best when it has opportunity for expression and when it is attracted by love rather than when it is driven by hate.

-WILLIAM A. WHITE in Crime and Criminals

FOREIGN PUBLICATIONS

THE CIRCLE (DER KREIS)

Published monthly since 1932, in French, German and English (no translation duplications); contains photos, illustrations and art reproductions, Rolf, editor. Annual subscriptions $11 first class sealed, Bank draft or cash to Lesezirkel Der Kreis, Postfach 547, Fraumunster, Zurich 22, Switzerland.

ICSE NEWSLETTER

Mimeographed English edition, published bi-monthly by International Committee for Sexual Equality, Jack Argo, editor. Annual subscriptions, $D. Address Postbox 1564, Amsterdam. Holland. (Single copies 50 cents each --may be ordered from Mattachine Review.)

VRIENDSCHAP

Monthly magazine in Dutch with articles about male and female homophile problems, published by Cultuur en Ontspannings Centrum (C.O.C.), Bob Angelo, editor. Subscriptions $4 per year. Address Postbox 542, Amsterdam, Holland.

ARCADIE

Monthly literary and scientific review in French, A. Baudry editor. Subscriptions $9 per year. Address 162 Rue Jeanne d'Arc. Paris 13, France.

Editor

HAROLD L. CALL

Associate Editor LEWIS C. CHRISTIE Business Manager DONALD S. LUCAS

Production Director HENRY FOSTER, JR. Treasurer

O. CONRAD BOWMAN, JR. Editorial Board

GONZALO SEGURA, JR. CARL B. HARDING DR. HENRI LORMIER MRS. LEAH GAILEY WALLACE DE ORTEGA MAXEY

Psychological Consultants

DR. PHYLLIS C. KRONHAUSEN DR. EBERHARD W. KRONHAUSEN

Published monthly by the Matta chine Society, Inc., 693 Mission St., San Francisco 5, California. Telephone EXbrook 7-0773.

Copyright 1959 by the Mattachine Society, Inc. Fifth year of publication. Mattachine Foundation, Inc., established in 1950 at Los Angeles; Mattachine Society formed in 1953 and chartered as non-profit, non. partisan educational, research and social service corporation in California. Founded in the public in• terest for purpose of providing true and accurate information leading to solution of sex bebavior problems, particularly those of the homosexual adult.

The REVIEW is available on many U.S. newsstands at 50c per copy, and by subscription (mailed in plain, sealed envelope). Rates in advance: $5 in U.S. and possessions; 56 foreign.

MATTACHINE AREA COUNCILS BOSTON 4, Mass.: P.O. Box 1499 DENVER 6, Colo.: P. O. Box 7035, Tel. Florida 5-3438 (Secretary) DETROIT 31, Mich.: P. O. Box 1434 LOS ANGELES 53, Calif.: P. O. Box 1925, Tel. Normandie 3-8033 NEW YORK 10, N.Y.: 1133 Broadway, Suite 304, Tel. WAtkins 4-7743 SAN FRANCISCO 5, Calif.: 693 Mission St., Tel. EXbrook 7-0773

mattachine REVIEW

Founded in 1954 First Issue January 1955

Volume V

SEPTEMBER 1959 Number 9

TABLE OF CONTENTS

2 Quote-Love v. Hate

4IMMORALITY AND TREASON, by H. L. A. Hart

10 SCIENTIFIC APPROACH NEEDED, by Walter

12 16

c. Alvarez, M. D.

TWELFTH NIGHT, by Willem Tomssen

PUNISHMENT, by Rev. Hallidie Smith

UNDESIRABLE DISCHARGES FROM AIR FORCE

20 READERS WRITE

GROUP THERAPY HELPS JAILED SEX OFFENDERS, by James Hubbart

WHY TEENAGERS FIND PARENTS DISINTERESTED, by Hal Boyle

28 HOMOPHILIC BIBLIOGRAPHY, Part XVII 30 BOOK REVIEWS

Cover Photo by Blythe. Posed by Dick Dawson, professional model.

ADVERTISEMENTS: Accepted only from publishers and/or authors of books; magazines; periodicals and booksellers concerned with homosexual and other sexological subjects. Rates upon application. MANUSCRIPTS: Original articles, reviews, letters and significant opinion, and appropriate short stories solicited for publication on a no-fee basis. Please include first class postage for return.

mattachine REVIEW